The Cincinnati Bengals' selection of Shemar Stewart in the first round of the 2025 draft has drawn considerable retrospective attention. His initial year with the team was complicated by a protracted contract negotiation and subsequent injuries, leading many to ponder alternative draft choices. This period of reflection highlights the unpredictable nature of rookie transitions in professional sports.
A recent re-evaluation of the 2025 draft class by Blake Brockermeyer from CBS Sports suggests a different path for the Bengals. In this hypothetical scenario, the team would have opted for safety Nick Emmanwori. Brockermeyer noted Emmanwori's versatility and elite skills, suggesting he would have been an ideal fit for the Bengals' defensive needs, particularly in addressing secondary concerns. This alternative pick gained traction due to Emmanwori's prior revelation that the Bengals had expressed interest in drafting him, adding a layer of "what if" to the discussion among fans.
Despite the speculation, Shemar Stewart's journey is far from over. He was a developmental prospect when he joined the Bengals and faced multiple physical setbacks during his rookie campaign. Towards the end of last year, after securing his first NFL sack, Stewart expressed a renewed determination to demonstrate his capabilities. The upcoming 2026 season presents a significant opportunity for him to step up, especially given the anticipated departure of Trey Hendrickson from the defense. Stewart is expected to play a crucial role alongside fellow first-rounder Myles Murphy in a reconfigured defensive lineup, aiming to prove his value and potential.
The ongoing discourse surrounding the 2025 draft pick underscores the intense scrutiny and high expectations placed on top selections in the NFL. While Stewart's first year did not yield immediate dividends, his potential for growth and contribution remains a key point of interest for the Bengals and their supporters. The team's strategy in navigating this situation, particularly in developing young talent, will be critical in shaping their future defensive strength.